latames
Saying ‘no’ when companies perform poorly on ESG

Saying ‘no’ when companies perform poorly on ESG

04-10-2022 | Visión

A stricter approach for governance and sustainability led to a higher number of votes against management during the AGM season.

  • Antonis Mantsokis
    Antonis
    Mantsokis
    Active Ownership Analyst
  • Michiel  van Esch
    Michiel
    van Esch
    Senior Engagement Specialist
  • Diana Trif
    Diana
    Trif
    Engagement Specialist
  • Lucas  van Beek
    Lucas
    van Beek
    Active Ownership Analyst

Speed read

  • Votes cast against management at 60% of all company meetings
  • Many Say on Pay and Say on Climate proposals rejected at AGMs
  • Social comes to the fore, provoking an ‘anti-ESG’ backlash

Hundreds of votes were cast against companies with inappropriate remuneration packages under the Say on Pay framework, and against most of those not doing enough to tackle their emissions under corporate Say on Climate proposals.

Historically, governance concerns are the main reason for shareholder dissent. But as environmental and social topics are becoming increasingly urgent, they are increasingly a reason why shareholders oppose management resolutions.

Resolutions were also opposed when insufficient progress was made on diversity, by directly voting against the reappointment of directors, often the chairman or other accountable board members.

It made for a lively voting season at the annual general meetings of more than 5,000 companies for Robeco’s voting specialists Antonis Mantsokis, Diana Trif and Lucas van Beek. They opposed at least one management proposal at 60% of the AGMs if expectations for environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues were not met.

Topics such as executive pay produced the most votes against management recommendations as a percentage of proposals in that category. Robeco did, however, support most ESG-related shareholder proposals, as shown in the chart below.

Conozca las perspectivas más recientes
Conozca las perspectivas más recientes
Suscríbase

A summary of Robeco’s voting season.

Holding companies accountable

“In recent years we have expanded our voting policy to hold companies accountable not only for aspects such as a lack of independence on boards, insufficient board gender diversity or poor compensation practices, but also for not taking sufficient action on climate change or on human rights and social concerns,” says Mantsokis, looking back on the voting season.

“For the Say on Pay, we assess a multitude of factors. We look at pay magnitude, at the alignment of pay with the company’s performance, the pay structure and transparency about it. What we saw this voting season were many issues related to a lack of alignment between pay and performance.”

“And we continue to see discretionary adjustments to pay outcomes. Many companies continue to be negatively impacted as a result of Covid, and therefore under the initial structure of most compensation plans, executives often should end up with lower bonuses. Yet, we have often seen companies makes some adjustments so that the executives end up with a bonus after all.”

The topics on which votes were cast for or against management.

Targeting the climate laggards

There was a major focus in the Say on Climate votes on what companies said they were doing to reduce emissions or decarbonize. “Many companies are making too little progress on climate in relation to their long-term commitments,” says Trif.

And where insufficient progress is being made, Robeco will hold the responsible directors to account by voting against the reappointment of directors, including the chairman.

“Over the last few years we have raised our concerns regarding the climate performance of these companies by voting against either the chair of the board, or the accounting report,” Trif says. “Our approach was to vote against if the companies were not taking sufficient steps in terms of climate, using benchmarks such as Climate Action 100+ and the Transition Pathway Initiative as the starting point for our analysis.”

Diversity still a big issue

Diversity and inclusion is another issue that raises temperatures at AGMs, given the persistent lack of women on boards, or corporate structures that recognize the skills of minorities.

“We were expecting social to have a prominent place on the agenda, and indeed that was the case,” says Mantsokis. “We saw a lot of resolutions focusing on promoting gender equality, disclosing gender pay gap and promoting living wages.”

Anti-ESG backlash

The drive for diversity has, however, caused a backlash in certain places, particularly in the US, where some are concerned it means hiring people who do not have the right skills, harming profitability. This has led to an ‘anti-ESG’ movement of people who file resolutions against social topics.

“This actually constitutes a concern for us – namely the fact that the number of anti-ESG proposals really increased,” says Trif. “These are proposals submitted by proponents that actually aim to hinder a company's efforts to advance ESG goals. A lot of anti-ESG proposals deal with social topics, that aim to hinder efforts to advance diversity or inclusion.”

“There has been a lot of social change over the last year with a focus on promoting diversity, inclusivity and discussing these topics more openly. Certain groups are trying to find any ways to halt this discussion. The bar has been raised, and some specific schools of thought are trying to reverse it.”

The majority of ESG-related proposals aimed to improve sustainability practices . Robeco supported most of the record 903 shareholder resolutions filed during AGM season.

Constructive feedback

So, how do the companies react when their resolutions are opposed, particularly when Robeco votes against the reappointment of directors? Do they take it personally?

“I think it really depends on the topic, the agenda item, and how we communicate with many companies,” says Michiel van Esch, senior manager for active ownership at Robeco, and a veteran of talking to companies directly. “We do have a dialogue, where we reach out to the company to give them some more information about our vote.”

“Companies generally welcome the opportunity to have a discussion and ask for feedback on how they can implement changes that could lead to higher support rates in the next year’s AGM. So, they don’t storm off in a huff.”

“They usually schedule a follow-up call where they can discuss with us what changes they want to implement and they again ask for our feedback. We think this is a positive development and we welcome it. Companies are really more open to hearing shareholder views.”

Logo

Información importante

Los Fondos Robeco Capital Growth no han sido inscritos conforme a la Ley de sociedades de inversión de Estados Unidos (United States Investment Company Act) de 1940, en su versión en vigor, ni conforme a la Ley de valores de Estados Unidos (United States Securities Act) de 1933, en su versión en vigor. Ninguna de las acciones puede ser ofrecida o vendida, directa o indirectamente, en los Estados Unidos ni a ninguna Persona estadounidense en el sentido de la Regulation S promulgada en virtud de la Ley de Valores de 1933, en su versión en vigor (en lo sucesivo, la “Ley de Valores”)). Asimismo, Robeco Institutional Asset Management B.V. (Robeco) no presta servicios de asesoramiento de inversión, ni da a entender que puede ofrecer este tipo de servicios, en los Estados Unidos ni a ninguna Persona estadounidense (en el sentido de la Regulation S promulgada en virtud de la Ley de Valores).

Este sitio Web está únicamente destinado a su uso por Personas no estadounidenses fuera de Estados Unidos (en el sentido de la Regulation S promulgada en virtud de la Ley de Valores) que sean inversores profesionales o fiduciarios profesionales que representen a dichos inversores que no sean Personas estadounidenses. Al hacer clic en el botón “Acepto” que se encuentra en el aviso sobre descargo de responsabilidad de nuestro sitio Web y acceder a la información que se encuentra en dicho sitio, incluidos sus subdominios, usted confirma y acepta lo siguiente: (i) que ha leído, comprendido y aceptado el presente aviso legal, (ii) que se ha informado de las restricciones legales aplicables y que, al acceder a la información contenida en este sitio Web, manifiesta que no infringe, ni provocará que Robeco o alguna de sus entidades o emisores vinculados infrinjan, ninguna ley aplicable, por lo que usted está legalmente autorizado a acceder a dicha información, en su propio nombre y en representación de sus clientes de asesoramiento de inversión, en su caso, (iii) que usted comprende y acepta que determinada información contenida en el presente documento se refiere a valores que no han sido inscritos en virtud de la Ley de Valores, y que solo pueden venderse u ofrecerse fuera de Estados Unidos y únicamente por cuenta o en beneficio de Personas no estadounidenses (en el sentido de la Regulation S promulgada en virtud de la Ley de Valores), (iv) que usted es, o actúa como asesor de inversión discrecional en representación de, una Persona no estadounidense (en el sentido de la Regulation S promulgada en virtud de la Ley de Valores) situada fuera de los Estados Unidos y (v) que usted es, o actúa como asesor de inversión discrecional en representación de, un inversión profesional no minorista. El acceso a este sitio Web ha sido limitado, de manera que no constituya intento de venta dirigida (según se define este concepto en la Regulation S promulgada en virtud de la Ley de Valores) en Estados Unidos, y que no pueda entenderse que a través del mismo Robeco dé a entender al público estadounidense en general que ofrece servicios de asesoramiento de inversión. Nada de lo aquí señalado constituye una oferta de venta de valores o la promoción de una oferta de compra de valores en ninguna jurisdicción. Nos reservamos el derecho a denegar acceso a cualquier visitante, incluidos, a título únicamente ilustrativo, aquellos visitantes con direcciones IP ubicadas en Estados Unidos.

Este sitio Web ha sido cuidadosamente elaborado por Robeco. La información de esta publicación proviene de fuentes que son consideradas fiables. Robeco no es responsable de la exactitud o de la exhaustividad de los hechos, opiniones, expectativas y resultados referidos en la misma. Aunque en la elaboración de este sitio Web se ha extremado la precaución, no aceptamos responsabilidad alguna por los daños de ningún tipo que se deriven de una información incorrecta o incompleta. El presente sitio Web podrá sufrir cambios sin previo aviso. El valor de las inversiones puede fluctuar. Rendimientos anteriores no son garantía de resultados futuros. Si la divisa en que se expresa el rendimiento pasado difiere de la divisa del país en que usted reside, tenga en cuenta que el rendimiento mostrado podría aumentar o disminuir al convertirlo a su divisa local debido a las fluctuaciones de los tipos de cambio. Para inversores profesionales únicamente. Prohibida su comunicación al público en general.

No estoy de acuerdo