Italian unrest returns with a vengeance

Italian unrest returns with a vengeance

05-01-2017 | Insight

Though the Italian government bond market has just calmed down since last month’s referendum, a new referendum is already looming. This poll aims to repeal Renzi’s labor market reform. Early elections are also becoming increasingly likely. In light of these events Robeco’s Global Fixed Income Macro Team has implemented a negative stance regarding Italian government bonds.

  • Kommer van Trigt
    van Trigt
    Portfolio manager, Head of Global Fixed Income Macro
  • Marck  Bulter
    Senior Portfolio Manager Global Fixed Income Macro

Speed read

  • New referendum aims to repeal major labor market reform
  • Rising risks of early elections
  • Robeco government bond portfolios positioned for rising Italian yields

Italy is making headlines and from an investors point of view not in a positive way. Banks are struggling with non-performing loans (NPLs), there is political instability and the country has Europe’s second-highest debt-to-GDP ratio after Greece. To name a few problems. “All of these issues are directly related to the structurally weak economic growth: on average, the Italian economy has shown no growth over the past 15 years and Italian productivity has not grown over the last 20 years”, explains Kommer van Trigt, lead portfolio manager of Robeco Global Total Return Bond Fund.

As regards NPLs: many Italian companies struggle to repay their bank loans due to a lack of domestic demand. Furthermore, support for protest parties is rising as unemployment remains high, with 36% youth unemployment. And the government debt has risen to more than 132% of GDP as GDP hardly grows and successive governments try to boost growth with further spending. Van Trigt: “Italy needs structurally stronger growth in order to address all of these problems, and stronger growth requires structural reforms. Renewed political turmoil obviously does not bode well for further reforms. Italy can hardly afford to roll back reforms – or to discuss leaving the Eurozone lightly, as the leader of the anti-Euro Five Star Movement (M5S) is currently doing.”

Stay informed on our latest insights with monthly mail updates
Stay informed on our latest insights with monthly mail updates

Another Italian referendum…

Italian labor unions have collected the necessary signatures to hold a referendum, aiming to repeal the recently implemented labor market reforms. These reforms were the main achievement of Renzi’s government. “Employment finally started to grow last year, which was likely related to this reform”, concludes Marck Bulter, portfolio manager for Robeco Euro Government Bonds.

On 11 January, the Constitutional Court will decide if all requirements have been met and if so, set a date for the referendum. According to the Italian newspaper Il Sole 24 Ore, there is a legal requirement to organize the referendum by no later than 15 June. Unlike the referendum last December, this referendum will have a quorum, meaning the turnout must be more than 50%. But given the importance of the topic and the previous referendum’s 70% turnout, the quorum can be met.

…or new general elections

The Italian government is worried about the referendum. Labor Minister Poletti stated that if the court approves the referendum, the government will ask the president to dissolve Parliament and call early elections. As a result, any forthcoming referendum would be postponed by twelve months. However, general elections also pose risks. According to the polls, the governing centre-left PD party is in a neck-and-neck race with M5S. Its leader Beppe Grillo is advocating a referendum on Italy’s membership of the Eurozone.

Bulter: “While calling such a referendum is legally complicated, the sole aim to do so could upset markets. Refinancing Italy’s two-trillion euros of sovereign debt at affordable rates would be challenging in the case of an abrupt Italian Euro-exit. But even if M5S will not be part of a new government, Berlusconi’s party seems the most reasonable coalition partner for Renzi’s PD party. This does not bode well for political stability and with a fragmented coalition it will be more difficult to push through reforms.”

‘Italy can hardly afford to roll back reforms or to discuss leaving the Eurozone lightly’

But under which electoral law?

Another complication Bulter foresees is that the electoral law is currently being contested before the Constitutional Court. “Calling new elections without a proper electoral law is a recipe for political turmoil.”

After the December referendum on reducing the powers of the Senate, President Mattarella has tasked the current government with aligning the electoral laws for the Parliament and the Senate. Under the current incongruent laws, political gridlock is highly likely. Furthermore, under the current electoral law (the Italicum) the most popular political party will automatically have a majority in Parliament. This increases the likelihood of M5S achieving an absolute majority. The Constitutional Court will rule on the Italicum on 24 January. The decision to call elections could be postponed until after this ruling.

Italian government bonds likely to come under pressure

While Italian government bonds have recovered since last month’s referendum, the outlook is not good. Early elections pose risks, given the rise of the anti-Euro M5S in the polls and the uncertainty about the electoral law. But a potential repeal of the main reform implemented by Renzi is also a negative.

“The necessary further reforms are unlikely to be implemented in either scenario, irrespective of whether early elections are called or the referendum is held”, says Van Trigt. “We are therefore negative on Italian government bonds and positioned our portfolios, including Robeco Global Total Return Bond Fund, Robeco All Strategy Euro Bonds and Robeco Euro Government Bonds, for rising Italian government bond yields.”

Subjects related to this article are:


The information contained in the website is solely intended for professional investors. Some funds shown on this website fall outside the scope of the Dutch Act on the Financial Supervision (Wet op het financieel toezicht) and therefore do not (need to) have a license from the Authority for the Financial Markets (AFM).

The funds shown on this website may not be available in your country. Please select your country website (top right corner) to view the products that are available in your country.

Neither information nor any opinion expressed on the website constitutes a solicitation, an offer or a recommendation to buy, sell or dispose of any investment, to engage in any other transaction or to provide any investment advice or service. An investment in a Robeco product should only be made after reading the related legal documents such as management regulations, prospectuses, annual and semi-annual reports, which can be all be obtained free of charge at this website and at the Robeco offices in each country where Robeco has a presence.

By clicking Proceed I confirm that I am a professional investor and that I have read, understood and accept the terms of use for this website.