switzerlanden
Schrödinger’s economy – when should we open the box?

Schrödinger’s economy – when should we open the box?

07-09-2022 | Monthly outlook
Knowing the true state of the US economy will be key to assessing risks for the coming months, says multi-asset investor Colin Graham.
  • Colin  Graham
    Colin
    Graham
    Head of Multi Asset Strategies and Co-Head of Sustainable Multi Asset Solutions

Speed read

  • Views vacillate between ‘US is in recession’ to ‘an opportunity to invest’
  • Data is contradictory as supply shocks are negative, job news positive
  • Uncertainty over corporate earnings means downside risks are growing

He likens the debate over whether the world’s largest economy is in recession to ‘Schrödinger's Cat’, a thought experiment conducted in 1935 by the Austrian physicist Erwin Schrödinger, a pioneer of quantum mechanics.

Schrödinger hypothesized that a cat in a closed box could be in two simultaneous states (dead and alive) based on whether a radioactive atom had decayed or not. If it had, emitting radiation, a flask of poison was broken, killing the cat. Only once the box is opened can the observer be sure which state the cat is in.

“We can read this across to the US economy because currently, observers do not know the true state of it,” says Graham, Head of Multi-Asset Strategies at Robeco. “Their views range from ‘we’re already in recession’ (two successive quarters of negative GDP growth) to ‘we’re expecting only a mild slowdown’ to ‘an opportunity to invest long term’. The consensus vacillates wildly between these outcomes on a weekly, daily or hourly basis.”

“Only with more time, more data and a hindsight lens will these two states of the economy be reconciled, and then market participants can open the metaphorical box. The additional complication is that we don’t have a good read on the baseline, as recent history has distorted the starting point of the initial Covid lockdowns to the subsequent fiscally simulated sugar highs.”

“Looking forwards, there are structural changes to the economy – hybrid working and blockchain – so even the historic baseline drawn through this volatility is in question.”

Stay informed on our latest insights with monthly mail updates
Stay informed on our latest insights with monthly mail updates
Subscribe

If the US sneezes, the world catches cold

The health of the US economy is vital for planning multi-asset investments since it influences the values of trillions of dollars of equities, government bonds, corporate bonds (credits), and the value of the dollar itself. A recession prompted by interest rate rises to combat inflation would cause both equities and government bonds to fall, making it difficult to know where to allocate capital.

“The US economy has been bombarded with many challenges over the last 12 months: raising rates, commodity and supply chain shocks, the cost of living squeeze and excess demand,” Graham says. “Yet, the lagging data such as employment, inflation and the cost of housing is still indicating a ‘strong economy’.”

“In our view, this tells us what we already know: that the US economy was alive before the bombardment. Monetary policy has moved away from ‘emergency’ levels and financial conditions have tightened, due to rates going up and the strength of the US dollar.”

“Hence, central banks are talking down the second-round effects of inflation and are moving to be more data-dependent. Our interpretation is that the central banks are moving to more real-time assessments of economic strength. In other words, watching inflation and employment levels is like driving a car by looking in the rear-view mirror.”

Equities and bonds price in different outcomes

So, what does this mean for investors as the fourth and final quarter of 2022 looms? “Investors are forward looking and try to anticipate the levels of returns over various time horizons, which is one of the reasons why markets are inefficient,” Graham says.

“In June, using our scenario analysis, we saw that the recent market low for equities and spread highs for credit began to price in different outcomes, with high yield expecting the outlook to be worse.”

“Market catalysts for the turnaround were interest rate expectations falling, bond yields falling, headline inflation moderating and earnings delivering, coupled with very bearish positioning. A very potent mix for a rally in risk assets.”

Decomposing the ‘Cat-alysts’

“If we decompose these catalysts – we might say ‘Schrödinger's Cat-alysts’ – to see which of them are sustainable, positioning is difficult to assess, as the data only gives you part of the story. But we can conclude that the broad sentiment indicators have moved from being extremely bearish to middle of the range, so there are no positive signals now.”

“Secondly, inflation is still high, and the Fed will continue to raise rates until aggregate demand starts to weaken, and employment softens enough to stabilize inflation in the medium term. Hence, the concern about over-tightening monetary policy, because interest rates are a blunt tool and supply-side issues are independent of central bank policy. And the Fed has never slowed the economy from these levels of employment and inflation without it resulting in a recession.”

“Lastly, the Q2 earnings season was good in aggregate, but scratch below the surface and the picture is less rosy, with the positive drivers coming from the energy sector and a narrow number of stocks.”

Downside risks are growing

This all leads to a gloomier outlook. “Looking forwards, consumer confidence is deteriorating while purchases are becoming less affordable, and the US first-time buyer affordability index is at lows seen in 2006 and 1989, which does not bode well as winter looms,” Graham says.

“Corporate balance sheets are in good shape and some sectors have passed on their rising input costs, but earnings delivery will become more challenging and confidence around the current level of earnings projected forward in valuations is questionable.”

“Hence, derating might be steeper than is currently priced in. As we progress to end of the year and get closer to opening Schrödinger’s box and seeing what state the US economy is really in, we believe the downside risks are growing.”

Logo

Disclaimer Robeco Switzerland Ltd.

The information contained on these pages is for marketing purposes and solely intended for Qualified Investors in accordance with the Swiss Collective Investment Schemes Act of 23 June 2006 (“CISA”) domiciled in Switzerland, Professional Clients in accordance with Annex II of the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive II (“MiFID II”) domiciled in the European Union und European Economic Area with a license to distribute / promote financial instruments in such capacity or herewith requesting respective information on products and services in their capacity as Professional Clients. 

The Funds are domiciled in Luxembourg and The Netherlands. ACOLIN Fund Services AG, postal address: Affolternstrasse 56, 8050 Zürich, acts as the Swiss representative of the Fund(s). UBS Switzerland AG, Bahnhofstrasse 45, 8001 Zurich, postal address: Europastrasse 2, P.O. Box, CH-8152 Opfikon, acts as the Swiss paying agent. The prospectus, the Key Investor Information Documents (KIIDs), the articles of association, the annual and semi-annual reports of the Fund(s) may be obtained, on simple request and free of charge, at the office of the Swiss representative ACOLIN Fund Services AG. The prospectuses are also available via the website www.robeco.ch. Some funds about which information is shown on these pages may fall outside the scope of the Swiss Collective Investment Schemes Act of 26 June 2006 (“CISA”) and therefore do not (need to) have a license from or registration with the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA). 

Some funds about which information is shown on this website may not be available in your domicile country. Please check the registration status in your respective domicile country. To view the RobecoSwitzerland Ltd. products that are registered/available in your country, please go to the respective Fund Selector, which can be found on this website and select your country of domicile. 

Neither information nor any opinion expressed on this website constitutes a solicitation, an offer or a recommendation to buy, sell or dispose of any investment, to engage in any other transaction or to provide any investment advice or service. An investment in a Robeco Switzerland Ltd. product should only be made after reading the related legal documents such as management regulations, prospectuses, annual and semi-annual reports. 

By clicking “I agree” you confirm that you/the company you represent falls under one of the above-mentioned categories of addressees and that you have read, understood and accept the terms of use for this website.

I Disagree