Exclusions in itself might not always be as impactful as we would wish, but they play an important role in the full suite of tools available to a sustainable investor. Exclusion can be especially useful when framed as potential repercussion for a company (or country) if they fail to meet the objectives set out as part of engagement.
Screenings always precede exclusions and can be divided into the type, based on controversial behavior (directly or after engagement); and the less common type, or even on country-level screening. All of these may result in exclusion.
There are further screening tools to align the investment universe with the intentions of a portfolio.
At Robeco, we make use of several types of screening depending on the intentions of the strategy that lead to exclusions. To give a few examples, we use the ‘blocks’ described below:
SDG screenings ensure the eligible investment universe is defined with companies meeting a threshold predefined by the SDGs
Stricter activity-based exclusions for fossil fuel activities apply for climate strategies
Negative screening is used to deselect low ESG-performing parts of the investment universe, for example for our Gender strategy
Screening to make sure we only capture those companies that contribute to a specific sustainable theme
On the surface exclusions may seem as the easy one of all the ESG building blocks available to a sustainable investor, but one step deeper and the view point may change. Exclusions are not ‘just’ exclusions; they require insight and research into companies operations and products as well as an integrated approach where multiple types of screening and active ownership tools may need to come together to ensure the intensions of an investor are properly addressed.