switzerlandde
Pension fund chooses maximum sustainability and low tracking error

Pension fund chooses maximum sustainability and low tracking error

16-09-2019 | Einblicke
Quant meets sustainability. A Dutch pension fund was looking for an investment solution aimed at generating market-like returns, but also featuring very high sustainability standards and offering a relatively low tracking error relative the market capitalization-weighted index.
  • Jan de Koning
    Jan
    de Koning
    Portfolio Manager

Speed read

  • Client brief: a ‘passive-like’ strategy with a superior sustainability profile
  • ESG Indexing can combine sustainability with low tracking error risk
  • Strategy maximizes sustainability while avoiding negative factor exposures

We developed an innovative solution, which we label ‘ESG Indexing’, that only uses active risk budget to allocate towards environmental, social and governance aspects (ESG) instead of well-known factor premiums. In fact, this is Robeco’s first quantitative approach that solely uses a stock selection list driven by ESG scores to offer clients a passive portfolio that is active with regards to ESG positioning.

Zu den aktuellen Einblicken
Zu den aktuellen Einblicken
Anmelden

The client’s needs

More specifically, this investor was looking for a strategy that would exclude from the investable universe the 25% worst-scoring stocks in terms of ESG and allow for the inclusion of other sustainable objectives, like lowering the carbon intensity of the portfolio. The client also wanted to exclude stocks of companies involved in the manufacture or distribution of tobacco products and controversial weapons. 

At the same time, they were aiming for returns similar to those achieved by a passive investment strategy, with a limited tracking error of only 1%. In addition, the client expected the strategy to remain flexible and allow for future additional sustainability customization.

Sponsored by a major Dutch financial institution, this pension fund considered itself a mainly passive investor, but it was also aware of the very high expectations among stakeholders concerning its ambitions in terms of sustainable investing. In other words, the trustees knew “all eyes were on them”. The fund was therefore willing to use any leeway available in terms of active share to tilt the portfolio towards more sustainable companies.

But while the client wanted to maximize potential enhancements in terms of sustainability, it was also reluctant to compromise on market returns. The risk with combining multiple sustainability objectives (e.g. a large exclusion list and ambitious targets for carbon intensity reduction and best-in-class investing) is that you end up with negative exposures to proven factors such as value, momentum, quality or low risk. These negative exposures may lead to underperformance relative to the market index, over long periods of time.

Robeco ESG Indexing

In this context, Robeco’s ESG Indexing strategy was soon found to be the best way forward. This innovative, rules-based investment approach lends itself particularly well to combining multiple sustainability goals while maintaining a low tracking error and delivering market-like returns.

The capitalization-weighted index is the starting point for ESG Indexing portfolios. Using an ESG-driven stock selection model and an innovative portfolio construction algorithm, slightly more weight is given to stocks with favorable sustainability characteristics and slightly less to unsustainable stocks.

When constructing the portfolio, the portfolio managers make sure that the target best-in-class score is achieved while the carbon footprint is reduced by 10%. Simultaneously, the algorithm keeps factor exposures in line with the benchmark.

Compared to most standard sustainability indices in the market, that only consider one dimension of sustainability integration, Robeco’s ESG Indexing optimizes the portfolio in order to achieve multiple goals simultaneously. 

This is done while preventing any negative factor exposures. Compared to more sophisticated custom ESG indices that can be replicated by a passive manager, Robeco’s Sustainable Enhanced Indexing offers a more significant ESG improvement per unit of tracking error.

Our approach allows for future customization if sustainability requirements or preferences change

Moreover, in contrast with standard sustainability indices, Robeco’s ESG Indexing allows for future customization if sustainability requirements or preferences change. Another important feature is the possibility to use investment flows to rebalance the portfolio in a smart way, instead of naively scaling up or down the portfolio, resulting in lower transaction costs. Finally, portfolio weights can be adjusted to actively integrate active ownership and engagement themes.

In terms of sustainability criteria, Robeco’s ESG Indexing approach offers several options for customization: exclusions, ESG integration and impact investing. Figure 1 illustrates these different options, that can be applied on various sorts of regional sectorial and even smart beta indices.

Figure 1: Flexible sustainability integration with Robeco ESG Indexing

Exclusions usually imply avoiding investments in controversial products or business practices, such as tobacco, weapons or thermal coal. 

Integration is about analyzing financially material information to be able to rank stocks, depending on the profile of companies, and favoring those with better ESG scores.

Impact investing enables investors to make a concrete socioeconomic impact in areas such as greenhouse gas emissions or waste generation. Impact investing even allows for the integration of the UN’s SDGs.

In this specific case, the solution chosen by the client uses a combination of those three approaches to sustainability integration:

  • exclusions: avoiding stocks of companies involved in the manufacture or distribution of tobacco products and controversial weapons
  • integration: avoiding companies with the poorest ESG scores
  • impact Investing: a 10% carbon intensity reduction relative to the benchmark
Logo

Zugangsbeschränkung / Haftungsausschluss

Die auf diesen Seiten enthaltenen Informationen dienen Marketingzwecken und sind ausschliesslich für (i) qualifizierte Anleger gemäss dem Schweizer Bundesgesetz über die kollektiven Kapitalanlagen vom 23. Juni 2006 („KAG“), (ii) Professionelle Kunden gemäss Anhang II der Richtlinie über Märkte für Finanzinstrumente (2014/65/EU; „MiFID II“) mit Sitz in der Europäischen Union oder im Europäischen Wirtschaftsraum mit einer entsprechenden Lizenz zur Erbringung von Vertriebs- / Angebotshandlungen im Zusammenhang mit Finanzinstrumenten oder für (iii) solche, die hiermit aus eigener Initiative entsprechende Informationen zu spezifischen Finanzinstrumenten erfragen und als professionelle Kunden qualifizieren.

Die Fonds haben ihren Sitz in Luxemburg oder den Niederlanden. Die ACOLIN Fund Services AG, Postanschrift: Affolternstrasse 56, 8050 Zürich, agiert als Schweizer Vertreter der Fonds. UBS Switzerland AG, Bahnhofstrasse 45, 8001 Zürich, Postanschrift: Europastrasse 2, P.O. Box, CH-8152 Opfikon, fungiert als Schweizer Zahlstelle. Der Prospekt, die Key Investor Information Documents (KIIDs), die Satzung, die Jahres- und Halbjahresberichte der Fonds sind auf einfache Anfrage hin und kostenlos im beim Schweizer Vertreter ACOLIN Fund Services AG erhältlich. Die Prospekte sind auch über die Website www.robeco.ch verfügbar.

Einige Fonds, über die Informationen auf dieser Website angezeigt werden, fallen möglicherweise nicht in den Geltungsbereich des KAG und müssen daher nicht über eine entsprechende Genehmigung durch die Eidgenössische Finanzmarktaufsicht FINMA verfügen. Einige Fonds sind in Ihrem Wohnsitz- / Sitzstaat möglicherweise nicht verfügbar. Bitte überprüfen Sie den Registrierungsstatus in Ihrem jeweiligen Wohnsitz- / Sitzstaat. Um die in Ihrem Land registrierten Produkte anzuzeigen, gehen Sie bitte zur jeweiligen Länderauswahl, die auf dieser Website zu finden ist, und wählen Sie Ihr Wohnsitz- / Sitzstaat aus.

Weder Informationen noch Meinungen auf dieser Website stellen eine Aufforderung, ein Angebot oder eine Empfehlung zum Kauf, Verkauf oder einer anderweitigen Verfügung eines Finanzinstrumentes dar. Die Informationen auf dieser Webseite stellen keine Anlageberatung oder anderweitige Dienstleistung der Robeco Switzerland Ltd dar. Eine Investition in ein Produkt von Robeco Switzerland Ltd sollte erst erfolgen, nachdem die entsprechenden rechtlichen Dokumente wie Verwaltungsvorschriften, Prospekt, Jahres- und Halbjahresberichte konsultiert wurden.

Durch Klicken auf "Ich stimme zu" bestätigen Sie, dass Sie resp. die von Ihnen vertretene juristische Person eine der oben genannten Kategorien von Adressaten fallen und dass Sie die Nutzungsbedingungen für diese Website gelesen, verstanden und akzeptiert haben.

Nicht Zustimmen