japanja
Are we heading for a bear market?

Are we heading for a bear market?

08-12-2017 | 月次アウトルック

A series of seemingly unstoppable stock market highs has left investors wondering if a correction is coming. But predicting one is harder than it looks, says Lukas Daalder, Chief Investment Officer of Robeco Investment Solutions.

  • Lukas Daalder
    Lukas
    Daalder
    Former CIO Robeco Investment Solutions. Daalder left Robeco in July 2018.

Speed read

  • Record number of all-time highs fuels fears of a correction
  • Predicting a bear market using valuation and volatility doesn’t work
  • Robeco remains overweight stocks, with a stop-loss in place
最新の「インサイト」を読む
最新の「インサイト」を読む
配信登録

The S&P 500 has closed at a fresh all-time high 57 times so far this year, while the Nasdaq has secured 70 new all-time high closes, shattering the 1999 record of 61. The fact that the 1999 rally was followed by a crash is making many people nervous, Daalder says.

Trying to see one coming though is not an exact science, as economists and academics cannot even agree on what constitutes a bear market, and not all stocks have become expensive due to the continuing bull market, he says.

“Concerns of an upcoming correction are spreading with each all-time high reached,” says Daalder, whose multi-asset fund remains overweight on stocks. “Reading through the various outlooks published by the major banks and institutions, the central theme is one of cautious optimism, with a clear emphasis on the caution part.”

Lofty levels

“The valuation of US stocks has reached lofty levels, while credit spreads have declined, regardless of the underlying deterioration of credit quality and overall leverage. Not surprisingly, more and more analysts are contemplating if, when and how the current rally in the risky parts of the US financial markets will come to an end.”

A recent Financial Stability Review by the European Central Bank flagged the high valuation of the US stock market, warning that any correction there would also pose a risk for the much cheaper European stock markets. But would it trigger a bear market?

“If you want to take a crack at predicting bear markets, you first need to have a clear idea of how to define one,” Daalder says. “Using one definition of ‘any 20% correction from the previous peak’ sounds simple, but it raises a number of questions.”

“Strictly interpreted, this means that the Nikkei index has been in a bear market for over 27 years. Although no one will claim that the Nikkei has been a solid investment, it does not do justice to the six 20%+ drawdowns that the index has experienced since the 1990s.”

“Another consideration may be that of inflation: the Brazilian Bovespa rose more than 1,000% in 1994, while inflation was as high as 5,000%. Most investors would qualify that as a bear market.”

Shiller’s definition

Daalder looks at the definition of the Nobel Prize-winning economist Robert Shiller: “The peak before a bear market, per my definition, was the most recent 12-month high, and there should be some month in the subsequent year that is 20% lower.” This means there have been 13 US bear markets since 1881 – the most recent one occurring during the Eurozone crisis of 2011 – but it still doesn’t tell the whole story, Daalder warns.

“The rule that a 20% correction needs to take place within 12 months means that you are filtering out the bear markets that take a bit longer to develop,” he says. “Additionally, whereas Shiller uses real prices in the construction of his famous Cyclical Adjusted Price Earnings ratio (CAPE, or Shiller PE), he sticks to a nominal approach. As a result, the 1970s and 1980s were ‘bear-free’, even though there were some pretty nasty corrections during that timeframe.”

The 13 US bear markets identified by Shiller.
Source: Shiller & Robeco

Considering volatility

The fact that high valuation increases the risk of a correction is probably not a shocking statement to make, but does low volatility add something to the mix as an early warning signal? Shiller seems to imply so by warning that in his US analysis, “stock price volatility was lower than average in the year leading up to the peak month preceding the 13 previous US bear markets”. This has led some investors to draw parallels with today’s low levels of volatility as a danger signal.

However, this is also unreliable, Daalder says. “Record low volatility is by no means a reliable early warning signal for spotting bear markets. Looking at the top-10 list of periods of record low volatility, only once (in 1895) did it precede a bear market: in the other nine cases there was no bear market sell-off. All in all, on a standalone basis, this does not appear to be a useful tool with which to flag a bear market.”

So what about looking at the combination of valuation and volatility? The table below attempts to do this by matching volatility levels with 12-month forward stock market returns. “If the combination of low volatility and high valuations have historically spelt trouble, one would expect the returns of the bottom left of the table to be lower on average than in the rest of the table (inside the red circle). But there does not appear to be a particular low point in that part of the matrix,” Daalder says.

The valuation volatility matrix for 12-month forward returns.
Source: Shiller & Robeco

“All in all, we do not think that there is much predictive value to be had by looking at the combination of valuation and volatility. Of course, we agree with the ECB and Shiller that the current valuation of US stocks is a cause for concern, but whether that means that we are heading for a correction anytime soon remains to be seen.”

“The current rally has been very much momentum and liquidity driven, and so far we see little signs that this is about to end. We therefore continue to be long on stocks, but with a tight stop loss in place.”

重要事項

当資料は情報提供を目的として、Robeco Institutional Asset Management B.V.が作成した英文資料、もしくはその英文資料をロベコ・ジャパン株式会社が翻訳したものです。資料中の個別の金融商品の売買の勧誘や推奨等を目的とするものではありません。記載された情報は十分信頼できるものであると考えておりますが、その正確性、完全性を保証するものではありません。意見や見通しはあくまで作成日における弊社の判断に基づくものであり、今後予告なしに変更されることがあります。運用状況、市場動向、意見等は、過去の一時点あるいは過去の一定期間についてのものであり、過去の実績は将来の運用成果を保証または示唆するものではありません。また、記載された投資方針・戦略等は全ての投資家の皆様に適合するとは限りません。当資料は法律、税務、会計面での助言の提供を意図するものではありません。

ご契約に際しては、必要に応じ専門家にご相談の上、最終的なご判断はお客様ご自身でなさるようお願い致します。

運用を行う資産の評価額は、組入有価証券等の価格、金融市場の相場や金利等の変動、及び組入有価証券の発行体の財務状況による信用力等の影響を受けて変動します。また、外貨建資産に投資する場合は為替変動の影響も受けます。運用によって生じた損益は、全て投資家の皆様に帰属します。したがって投資元本や一定の運用成果が保証されているものではなく、投資元本を上回る損失を被ることがあります。弊社が行う金融商品取引業に係る手数料または報酬は、締結される契約の種類や契約資産額により異なるため、当資料において記載せず別途ご提示させて頂く場合があります。具体的な手数料または報酬の金額・計算方法につきましては弊社担当者へお問合せください。

当資料及び記載されている情報、商品に関する権利は弊社に帰属します。したがって、弊社の書面による同意なくしてその全部もしくは一部を複製またはその他の方法で配布することはご遠慮ください。

商号等: ロベコ・ジャパン株式会社  金融商品取引業者 関東財務局長(金商)第2780号

加入協会: 一般社団法人 日本投資顧問業協会