switzerlandde
We need decarbonization, not divestment

We need decarbonization, not divestment

19-12-2017 | Einblicke

Assessing climate risks in an investment portfolio can be a hell of a job. Investors who want to reduce this risk and also make an impact in speeding up energy transition are looking for ways to do this… but how?

Speed read

  • Divestment simply transfers a problem and can be negative
  • Focus should be on innovation that lowers carbon emissions
  • Three ways to look at winners and sinners when buying stocks

A common instrument used is decarbonization of the investment portfolio: this means measuring the carbon footprint of the fund and reducing it by selling the largest contributors. This is a good first start, but there are several other issues to be considered, says Masja Zandbergen, Head of ESG Integration at Robeco.

“The largest contributors are often only found in a few CO2 intensive sectors, meaning you will divest from those sectors completely, and therefore have no impact on the much-needed energy transition,” she says.

“The current footprint of a company does not necessarily say anything about its future footprint. If one were to take two identical companies with the same footprint, but one company is considering making an energy transition of strategic importance and is preparing for the future, it is clear which company you would want to invest in.”

“Meanwhile, by only measuring the footprint of the company’s operations, and the energy used in these operations, you miss part of the risk. What about the use of the company’s products? A car maker might be less carbon intensive than another manufacturer, but its products have a high carbon footprint through emissions. And the risks lie in a change in market behavior and preferences too, for example, in the switch to electric cars.”

“Similarly, a food company has high exposure to agriculture, and thereby to generating large amounts of CO2 emissions in its supply chain. What about companies whose clients are all in the energy sector? It’s not as simple as it looks.”

Aktuelle Einblicke zum Thema Nachhaltigkeit
Aktuelle Einblicke zum Thema Nachhaltigkeit
Anmelden

Divesting transfers a problem

These issues were illustrated by Isabel Reuss, Portfolio Manager for European SRI Equities at Allianz Global Investors, at a recent Sustainability Investing Forum that Allianz GI jointly hosted with Robeco. She says divestment simply transfers a problem, and an investor cannot sell out of an entire sector anyway if they want to make a long-term impact.

Creating a lower-carbon society effectively means investing in things such as more efficient buildings and renewables to keep global warming below two degrees Celsius – so it is therefore impossible to avoid the energy, materials and utilities sectors while doing so, she says. Instead, extensive engagement with the largest generators of greenhouse gas emissions is necessary.

“Does divesting make an impact? No; at best it is neutral and at worse it may even be negative,” says Reuss. “Achieving a lower-carbon economy means you must use energy, materials and utilities. Divesting an entire sector may lower the carbon footprint of a portfolio, but it makes absolutely no impact on the environment.”

The need to engage

“We want to reach a two-degree economy, so how are we going to do that if we don’t use these three sectors?  If you divest it, whoever is buying it is not interested in climate – so they’re not sitting at the table. We cannot then discuss climate with divested companies, or engage with them.”

Reuss cites the example of building insulation, which has a net beneficial effect on the environment. “For every kilogram of CO2 emitted in the production of insulation, 330 kg of emissions are avoided once it is installed,” she says. “It is part of the materials sector, so if everybody divests that, then why would the sector invest in R&D to find better insulation materials? It’s not black and white.”

Reuss says that in terms of portfolio construction, there are three dimensions to choosing stocks: the companies that are the best performers in cutting carbon; those that are making the best efforts to reduce emissions; and those offering the best solutions for others. This is shown in the graphic below.

Finding solutions

“For us, the best solution is looking at something like washing detergent,” Reuss says. “What if a company makes an enzyme that means you can wash your whites at zero degrees, using less energy, and it still all comes out white. This is something that has a real impact. We need to find solutions; you have to look for them and find them.”

Robeco and RobecoSAM believe that such solutions like plainly in portfolio construction, using enhanced research, Zandbergen says. “This can be done first of all by decarbonizing the portfolio to reducing its environmental footprint, and then adding a more forward-looking component by using the environmental score of the RobecoSAM Corporate Sustainability Assessment to assess which companies are more adaptive to this issue,” she says.

“Furthermore, engagement is used as a tool to address these issues at companies, encourage them to make the transition, and gain more information for our investment teams to apply at the same time. Finally, we can invest in companies that are providing a solution to climate change, such as green bonds in our credit portfolios. That then makes a difference.”

Logo

Zugangsbeschränkung / Haftungsausschluss

Die auf diesen Seiten enthaltenen Informationen dienen Marketingzwecken und sind ausschliesslich für (i) qualifizierte Anleger gemäss dem Schweizer Bundesgesetz über die kollektiven Kapitalanlagen vom 23. Juni 2006 („KAG“), (ii) Professionelle Kunden gemäss Anhang II der Richtlinie über Märkte für Finanzinstrumente (2014/65/EU; „MiFID II“) mit Sitz in der Europäischen Union oder im Europäischen Wirtschaftsraum mit einer entsprechenden Lizenz zur Erbringung von Vertriebs- / Angebotshandlungen im Zusammenhang mit Finanzinstrumenten oder für (iii) solche, die hiermit aus eigener Initiative entsprechende Informationen zu spezifischen Finanzinstrumenten erfragen und als professionelle Kunden qualifizieren.

Die Fonds haben ihren Sitz in Luxemburg oder den Niederlanden. Die ACOLIN Fund Services AG, Postanschrift: Affolternstrasse 56, 8050 Zürich, agiert als Schweizer Vertreter der Fonds. UBS Switzerland AG, Bahnhofstrasse 45, 8001 Zürich, Postanschrift: Europastrasse 2, P.O. Box, CH-8152 Opfikon, fungiert als Schweizer Zahlstelle. Der Prospekt, die Key Investor Information Documents (KIIDs), die Satzung, die Jahres- und Halbjahresberichte der Fonds sind auf einfache Anfrage hin und kostenlos im beim Schweizer Vertreter ACOLIN Fund Services AG erhältlich. Die Prospekte sind auch über die Website www.robeco.ch verfügbar.

Einige Fonds, über die Informationen auf dieser Website angezeigt werden, fallen möglicherweise nicht in den Geltungsbereich des KAG und müssen daher nicht über eine entsprechende Genehmigung durch die Eidgenössische Finanzmarktaufsicht FINMA verfügen. Einige Fonds sind in Ihrem Wohnsitz- / Sitzstaat möglicherweise nicht verfügbar. Bitte überprüfen Sie den Registrierungsstatus in Ihrem jeweiligen Wohnsitz- / Sitzstaat. Um die in Ihrem Land registrierten Produkte anzuzeigen, gehen Sie bitte zur jeweiligen Länderauswahl, die auf dieser Website zu finden ist, und wählen Sie Ihr Wohnsitz- / Sitzstaat aus.

Weder Informationen noch Meinungen auf dieser Website stellen eine Aufforderung, ein Angebot oder eine Empfehlung zum Kauf, Verkauf oder einer anderweitigen Verfügung eines Finanzinstrumentes dar. Die Informationen auf dieser Webseite stellen keine Anlageberatung oder anderweitige Dienstleistung der Robeco Switzerland Ltd dar. Eine Investition in ein Produkt von Robeco Switzerland Ltd sollte erst erfolgen, nachdem die entsprechenden rechtlichen Dokumente wie Verwaltungsvorschriften, Prospekt, Jahres- und Halbjahresberichte konsultiert wurden.

Durch Klicken auf "Ich stimme zu" bestätigen Sie, dass Sie resp. die von Ihnen vertretene juristische Person eine der oben genannten Kategorien von Adressaten fallen und dass Sie die Nutzungsbedingungen für diese Website gelesen, verstanden und akzeptiert haben.

Nicht Zustimmen